Boston Red Sox at New York Yankees Player Props, Picks and Predictions - 9/12/2024 7:15 PM EST

We have your Boston Red Sox at New York Yankees prop betting and game preview needs covered as the Boston Red Sox hit the road to face the New York Yankees.

Boston Red Sox at New York Yankees Odds Info

Best Moneyline Odds: Boston Red Sox +162 (Caesars) / New York Yankees -185 (BetMGM)
Best Spread Odds: -1.5 - Boston Red Sox -125 (ESPN BET) / New York Yankees +118 (BetRivers)
Best Total Odds: 9.0 - Under -120 (BetMGM) / 8.5 - Over -122 (FanDuel)

Game Info

Date: 9/12/2024
Time: 7:15 PM EST
Location: Yankee Stadium (Bronx, New York)
TV: FOX

Boston Red Sox at New York Yankees Preview

The Boston Red Sox and New York Yankees are set to renew their storied rivalry in a crucial four-game series at Yankee Stadium. Both teams are vying for postseason positions, with the Yankees holding a slim lead in the American League East and the Red Sox making a late push for a Wild Card spot. The Yankees, with an 84-62 record, have been formidable at home, boasting a 39-32 record at Yankee Stadium. They lead the AL with 216 home runs, showcasing their power-hitting prowess.

On the mound for the Yankees is Nestor Cortes Jr., who has been a reliable presence with a 9-10 record and a 3.97 ERA. Despite the team's 12-17 record in games he has started, Cortes has often been let down by a lack of run support rather than poor pitching. The Yankees will look to capitalize on their home-field advantage and Cortes' ability to keep the Red Sox hitters in check.

The Red Sox, with a 74-72 record, have shown resilience on the road, matching the Yankees' home record with a 39-32 mark away from Fenway Park. They are coming off a series win against the Orioles, highlighted by Tyler O'Neill's walk-off home run, his fifth in six games. O'Neill's hot streak has been a catalyst for Boston's recent success, and they will need his bat to stay hot against a Yankees team that has been tough to beat at home.

Cooper Criswell will take the mound for Boston, bringing a 6-4 record and a 4.11 ERA into the game. Criswell has been effective in his recent starts, but his low swinging strike rate suggests he will need to rely on precise location and favorable calls to navigate the Yankees' potent lineup. The Red Sox bullpen, which has been exposed in previous matchups against New York, will need to be sharp to support Criswell and keep the game within reach.

Both teams are coming off dramatic walk-off victories, setting the stage for an intense series opener. The Yankees' recent offensive struggles, particularly Aaron Judge's slump, will be a focal point, but their overall power and depth make them a formidable opponent. The Red Sox, buoyed by their recent form and O'Neill's heroics, will aim to continue their push for a playoff berth. With both teams capable of explosive offensive performances, this matchup promises to be a high-scoring affair, adding another thrilling chapter to their historic rivalry.

Boston Red Sox at New York Yankees Pick: Total Runs Over

The upcoming clash between the Boston Red Sox and the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium is poised to be a high-scoring affair, making the over on total runs a compelling pick. Both teams have demonstrated offensive prowess, with the Yankees leading the American League in home runs, boasting a formidable lineup that has consistently delivered power at the plate. Despite Aaron Judge's recent slump, the Yankees' depth in their batting order remains a significant threat, especially in the hitter-friendly confines of Yankee Stadium.

On the other side, the Red Sox have been riding a wave of offensive momentum, particularly with Tyler O'Neill's scorching form. O'Neill has been a revelation, hitting five home runs in his last six games, including a dramatic walk-off against the Orioles. His hot streak has been instrumental in Boston's recent success, and his ability to change the game with a single swing adds to the potential for a high-scoring contest.

Pitching matchups further support the case for the over. While Nestor Cortes Jr. has been reliable for the Yankees, the team's record in his starts suggests vulnerability, often due to a lack of run support rather than his pitching. Meanwhile, Cooper Criswell's recent performances for the Red Sox, though effective, have relied heavily on precise location and favorable calls, which may not suffice against the Yankees' potent lineup. Additionally, the Red Sox bullpen has shown susceptibility in previous encounters with New York, often allowing multiple runs in the later innings.

Historical trends between these two storied rivals also point towards a high-scoring game. In their last five matchups, the total has gone over in four, with the Yankees scoring seven or more runs in each of those contests. Given the offensive capabilities of both teams and the potential for fireworks in this crucial series opener, betting on the total runs to go over is a strategic choice that aligns with recent performances and statistical trends.

Boston Red Sox at New York Yankees Top Player Prop Picks

Nestor Cortes Over 5.5 Strikeouts -112 (FanDuel)

Nestor Cortes has been a reliable presence on the mound for the Yankees, and his strikeout potential is a key factor in this matchup against the Red Sox. Despite the Yankees' 12-17 record in games he has started, Cortes has often been let down by a lack of run support rather than his pitching performance. With a 3.97 ERA and 147 strikeouts over 163 1/3 innings, Cortes has demonstrated his ability to miss bats. The Red Sox lineup, while potent, has shown vulnerability to strikeouts, averaging 8.5 strikeouts per nine innings this season. Given Cortes' track record and the Red Sox's tendency to strike out, the over on 5.5 strikeouts is a compelling pick.

Tyler O'Neill Over 0.5 Runs Scored -105 (DraftKings)

Tyler O'Neill has been on a remarkable hot streak, hitting five home runs in his last six games, including a walk-off against the Orioles. His recent form has been a catalyst for the Red Sox's offensive surge, and his ability to get on base and score runs is crucial for Boston's success. With the Yankees' bullpen potentially stretched after an extra-inning game against the Royals, O'Neill's chances of crossing the plate are heightened. His current form and the Yankees' bullpen situation make the over on 0.5 runs scored a strong proposition.

Aaron Judge Under 0.5 Singles -140 (bet365)

Aaron Judge, despite leading the MLB in OPS, home runs, and RBIs, is currently experiencing a slump, having not hit a home run since August 25. In his last 15 games, Judge's slugging percentage has dropped significantly, and he has struggled to find consistency at the plate. With Cooper Criswell on the mound for the Red Sox, who has been effective in limiting hits, Judge may find it challenging to break out of his slump. Given his recent struggles and Criswell's ability to induce weak contact, the under on 0.5 singles is a prudent choice.