New York Yankees vs. Cleveland Guardians Player Props, Picks and Predictions - 10/19/2024 8:08 PM EST

We have your New York Yankees vs. Cleveland Guardians prop betting and game preview needs covered as the New York Yankees hit the road to face the Cleveland Guardians.

New York Yankees vs. Cleveland Guardians Odds Info

Best Moneyline Odds: New York Yankees -118 (FanDuel) / Cleveland Guardians +100 (DraftKings)
Best Spread Odds: 1.5 - New York Yankees +146 (FanDuel) / Cleveland Guardians -170 (DraftKings)
Best Total Odds: 7.5 - Under -120 (DraftKings) / Over +100 (DraftKings)

Game Info

Date: 10/19/2024
Time: 8:08 PM EST
Location: Progressive Field (Cleveland, Ohio)
TV: TBS

New York Yankees Betting Trends

On the road, the New York Yankees have 53 wins and 32 losses this season.
As the favorite, the New York Yankees have 89 wins and 65 losses this season.
This season, the New York Yankees have hit 88 overs, 76 unders and pushed 6 times.

Cleveland Guardians Betting Trends

At home, the Cleveland Guardians have 53 wins and 32 losses this season.
As the favorite, the Cleveland Guardians have 31 wins and 34 losses this season.
This season, the Cleveland Guardians have hit 72 overs, 90 unders and pushed 8 times.

Historic Head-to-Head Stats and Analysis

Over the past month, the New York Yankees and Cleveland Guardians have faced off in four playoff games, with the Yankees emerging victorious in three of those contests. The Yankees have consistently outperformed the Guardians, winning both at home and on the road, while the Guardians managed to secure a single win at home. In terms of betting outcomes, the Yankees have covered the spread in three games, while the Guardians have done so only once. The games have generally been high-scoring affairs, with the total score going over the set line in three of the four matchups, and only one game falling under. The Yankees have demonstrated a strong offensive presence, consistently putting pressure on the Guardians' pitching staff.

In the most recent game on October 18, 2024, the Yankees defeated the Guardians 8-6 in a closely contested matchup. The Yankees took an early lead with a home run by Juan Soto in the first inning, followed by another homer from Austin Wells in the second. Giancarlo Stanton further extended the Yankees' lead with a three-run homer in the sixth inning. The Guardians mounted a comeback in the seventh inning, with José Ramírez and Josh Naylor contributing key hits to tie the game at 6-6. However, the Yankees capitalized on defensive errors by the Guardians in the ninth inning, securing the win with runs from Jon Berti and Gleyber Torres. The Yankees recorded 10 hits and three home runs, while the Guardians had 11 hits but struggled to convert opportunities, leaving 23 runners on base.

The Yankees' recent success against the Guardians has been marked by their ability to capitalize on scoring opportunities and maintain offensive pressure throughout the games. Their pitching staff has managed to hold the Guardians' offense in check, despite some late-inning rallies. The Guardians, on the other hand, have shown resilience in their attempts to come back from deficits but have been unable to consistently close out games. As the two teams prepare to face each other again, the Yankees will look to continue their winning momentum, while the Guardians will aim to improve their execution and capitalize on their scoring chances.

New York Yankees vs. Cleveland Guardians Preview

The New York Yankees and Cleveland Guardians are set to clash in a pivotal Game 5 of the American League Championship Series at Progressive Field. The Yankees, leading the series 3-1, are on the brink of their first World Series appearance since 2009, while the Guardians are fighting to keep their season alive. The Yankees have demonstrated resilience and offensive prowess throughout the series, highlighted by Giancarlo Stanton's clutch performances and Juan Soto's timely power hitting. Stanton, who has been a force in the postseason, tied Babe Ruth and Aaron Judge for the fourth-most home runs in Yankees playoff history with his recent blasts.

On the mound, the Yankees will rely on left-hander Carlos Rodón, who delivered a strong performance in Game 1, allowing just one run over six innings with nine strikeouts. Rodón's ability to neutralize the Guardians' lineup will be crucial as the Yankees aim to close out the series. The Guardians, meanwhile, will turn to right-hander Tanner Bibee, who is pitching on short rest after a brief outing in Game 2. Bibee, who has been a reliable arm for Cleveland throughout the season, will need to harness his frustrations from his previous start and deliver a standout performance to extend the series.

The Guardians have shown flashes of resilience, particularly in their dramatic Game 3 victory, but have struggled to maintain consistency against the Yankees' potent lineup. Cleveland's bullpen, once a strength, has been vulnerable, with closer Emmanuel Clase faltering in consecutive games. The Guardians' offense, led by José Ramírez and Josh Naylor, will need to capitalize on scoring opportunities and support their pitching staff to force a Game 6.

As the series returns to Cleveland, the Yankees will look to continue their offensive momentum and capitalize on any defensive lapses by the Guardians. With both teams having demonstrated the ability to score in bunches, fans can expect another high-stakes, high-scoring affair as the Yankees seek to punch their ticket to the Fall Classic, while the Guardians fight to keep their World Series dreams alive.

New York Yankees vs. Cleveland Guardians Pick: Total Runs Over

The upcoming Game 5 of the American League Championship Series between the New York Yankees and the Cleveland Guardians promises to be another high-scoring affair, making the over on total runs a compelling pick. Throughout the series, both teams have demonstrated their offensive capabilities, with the Yankees consistently putting pressure on the Guardians' pitching staff. In the four playoff games so far, the total score has gone over the set line in three of them, highlighting the offensive prowess on display.

The Yankees have been particularly potent at the plate, with Giancarlo Stanton and Juan Soto leading the charge. Stanton's postseason heroics have been crucial, as he has tied Babe Ruth and Aaron Judge for the fourth-most home runs in Yankees playoff history. His ability to deliver in clutch moments, combined with Soto's power hitting, has been a significant factor in the Yankees' success. In Game 4, the Yankees recorded 10 hits and three home runs, showcasing their ability to capitalize on scoring opportunities.

On the other side, the Guardians have shown resilience, particularly in their dramatic Game 3 victory, where they rallied late to secure a win. Despite their struggles, the Guardians' offense, led by José Ramírez and Josh Naylor, has the potential to put up runs, as evidenced by their 11 hits in Game 4. However, their inability to convert opportunities, leaving 23 runners on base, has been a hindrance. With their backs against the wall, the Guardians will be motivated to break through and support their pitching staff.

Both teams have demonstrated vulnerabilities in their bullpens, with the Guardians' closer Emmanuel Clase faltering in consecutive games. This has opened the door for late-inning scoring, further supporting the case for a high-scoring game. As the series returns to Cleveland, the offensive firepower of both teams, combined with the recent bullpen struggles, suggests that the total runs will once again exceed expectations. Fans can anticipate another thrilling, high-stakes matchup as the Yankees aim to clinch their World Series berth, while the Guardians fight to extend their season.

New York Yankees vs. Cleveland Guardians Top Player Prop Picks

Carlos Rodon Over 5.5 Strikeouts -104 (FanDuel)

Carlos Rodon has been a formidable force on the mound for the Yankees, particularly in the postseason. In Game 1 of the ALCS, Rodon delivered a stellar performance, striking out nine Guardians over six innings. His ability to neutralize Cleveland's lineup was evident, and with the Yankees on the brink of a World Series berth, Rodon will be motivated to replicate his success. The Guardians have struggled against strong pitching, and Rodon's track record suggests he can surpass the 5.5 strikeout line. Given his postseason form and the Guardians' offensive inconsistencies, betting on Rodon to exceed this strikeout total is a compelling choice.

Giancarlo Stanton Over 0.5 Total Bases -148 (Caesars)

Giancarlo Stanton has been a pivotal player for the Yankees throughout the postseason, consistently delivering in crucial moments. His recent performances have been nothing short of spectacular, tying Babe Ruth and Aaron Judge for the fourth-most home runs in Yankees playoff history. Stanton's power and ability to find gaps in the defense make him a constant threat at the plate. With the Yankees looking to close out the series, Stanton's presence will be crucial, and his track record suggests he will continue to accumulate total bases. Given his current form and the Guardians' bullpen struggles, the over on 0.5 total bases is a strong pick.

Gleyber Torres Over 0.5 Singles -142 (Caesars)

Gleyber Torres has been a consistent contributor for the Yankees, particularly in this series against the Guardians. His ability to get on base and create scoring opportunities has been vital for New York's offensive success. In Game 4, Torres delivered a crucial RBI single in the ninth inning, showcasing his knack for timely hitting. With the Yankees aiming to secure their World Series spot, Torres will be looking to maintain his form and continue to find gaps in the Guardians' defense. Considering his recent performances and the odds offered, betting on Torres to record at least one single is a prudent choice.