New York Islanders @ Columbus Blue Jackets Player Props, Picks and Predictions - 4/17/2025 7:00 PM EDT

We have your New York Islanders @ Columbus Blue Jackets prop betting and game preview needs covered as the Columbus Blue Jackets host the New York Islanders in what promises to be an exciting NHL matchup.

New York Islanders @ Columbus Blue Jackets Pick

Best Moneyline Odds: Columbus Blue Jackets -135, New York Islanders +114.
Best Spread Odds: -
Best Total Odds: -

Game Info

Date: April 17, 2025
Time: 7:00 PM EDT
Location: Nationwide Arena, Columbus, OH
TV: -

New York Islanders @ Columbus Blue Jackets Preview

The Columbus Blue Jackets enter this game with a 39-33-9 record, while the New York Islanders stand at 35-34-12. Columbus has had a solid season but fell short of playoff contention, making this their final game of the season. The Islanders, on the other hand, have struggled with consistency and will look to end their season on a high note. Both teams will aim to showcase their talent and finish strong, making this an intriguing matchup for fans and bettors alike.

Historic Head-to-Head Stats and Analysis

The New York Islanders have dominated the recent head-to-head series, going 10-3 straight up (SU) in their last 13 games against the Columbus Blue Jackets. Additionally, the total has gone OVER in five of the Islanders' last six road games, indicating a trend toward high-scoring affairs when these teams meet.

Pick: Columbus Blue Jackets Moneyline (-135)

widget-odds-nhl-su-5681-NYI-CBJ

The Columbus Blue Jackets are slight favorites at home, and for good reason. While the Islanders have had success in the head-to-head series, Columbus has been the more consistent team this season. Playing at Nationwide Arena gives them an edge, and with the Islanders' struggles on the road, the Blue Jackets are the safer pick to win outright.

Top Player Prop Picks

1. Boone Jenner Over 0.5 Goals

widget-props-nhl-5681-2280646

Boone Jenner has been a key offensive contributor for the Blue Jackets this season. Facing an Islanders team that has allowed high-scoring games on the road, Jenner is a strong candidate to find the back of the net.

2. Mathew Barzal Over 2.5 Shots on Goal

Barzal is a dynamic playmaker for the Islanders and often leads the team in offensive opportunities. With Columbus allowing a fair number of shots per game, Barzal should easily surpass this line.

3. Elvis Merzlikins Over 28.5 Saves

As the Blue Jackets' goaltender, Merzlikins is likely to face a high volume of shots from the Islanders. Given the Islanders' offensive tendencies, this prop offers solid value.

Free Picks available for new customers at: