2014 NFL Expert Picks Week 21

A free ad-click funded site comparing every expert’s NFL picks from ESPN, FOX, CBS, Bleacher Report and more. Sign up here to have your picks tracked this year and beyond…  and for Against the Spread click here.

Week 21

View Previous Weeks > 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21


NEW! - View NFL Pickwatch's Top 10 Consensus
View our data as text only
@
CONSENSUS53%WEEKSEASON
# Name Affil Picks W L % W L %
1Cris CarterESPN000%1877870%
2ESPN FansESPN000%1867970%
3Pickwatch UsersPickwatch000%1867970%
4AccuscoreAccuscore000%1848169%
5Dave DameshekNFL000%1848169%
6FiveThirtyEightFiveThirtyEightNO
PICK
000%1848169%
7Jamey EisenbergCBS000%1848169%
8K.C. JoynerESPN000%1838269%
9Dan HanzusNFLNO
PICK
000%1828368%
10Expert ConsensusNoneNO
PICK
000%1828368%
11Gary DavenportBleacher Report000%1828368%
12Ron JaworskiESPN000%1828368%
13Tom JacksonESPNNO
PICK
000%1828368%
14Brendon AyanbadejoFOXNO
PICK
000%1818468%
15Gregg RosenthalNFL000%1818468%
16Jim CorbettUSA TodayNO
PICK
000%1818468%
17Lorenzo ReyesUSA TodayNO
PICK
000%1818468%
18Matt MillerBleacher Report000%1818468%
19Nate DavisUSA TodayNO
PICK
000%1818468%
20Vegas LineVegasNO
PICK
000%1818468%
21Yahoo UsersYahoo000%1818468%
22Gordon McGuinnessProFootballFocusNO
PICK
000%1808567%
23NFL FAN PICKSNFL000%1808567%
24NumberfireESPN000%1808567%
25TeamrankingsESPN000%1808567%
26Brad GagnonBleacher Report000%1798667%
27Elliot HarrisonNFL000%1798667%
28Microsoft CortanaMicrosoft000%1798667%
29Pete PriscoCBS000%1798667%
30Ben StockwellProFootballFocusNO
PICK
000%1788767%
31Don BanksSports IllustratedNO
PICK
000%1788767%
32Marc SesslerNFL000%1788767%
33Mark MaloneWestwood OneNO
PICK
000%1788767%
34Seth WickershamESPN000%1788767%
35WhatifsportsFOX000%1788767%
36Chris SimmsBleacher Report000%1778866%
37Jimmy TrainaFOXNO
PICK
000%1778866%
38Matt BowenBleacher Report000%1778866%
39Mike FlorioPFTNO
PICK
000%1778866%
40Prediction MachinePrediction Machine000%1778866%
41Gary MihocesUSA TodayNO
PICK
000%1768966%
42Kevin PatraNFL000%1768966%
43Michael IrvinNFLNO
PICK
000%1768966%
44Vinnie IyerSporting NewsNO
PICK
000%1768966%
45Bruce MurraySiriusNO
PICK
000%1759066%
46Michael FabianoNFLNO
PICK
000%1759066%
47Steve MariucciNFLNO
PICK
000%1759066%
48Steve PalazzoloProFootballFocusNO
PICK
000%1759066%
49Josh KatzowitzCBSNO
PICK
000%1749165%
50Michael David SmithPFTNO
PICK
000%1749165%
51Michael SchotteyBleacher Report000%1749165%
52Rich EisenNFLNO
PICK
000%1749165%
53Adam RonisSiriusNO
PICK
000%1739265%
54Adam SchefterESPN000%1739265%
55Alex MarvezFOXNO
PICK
000%1739265%
56Dr. RotoSiriusNO
PICK
000%1739265%
57Eric AllenESPN000%1739265%
58James LoftonWestwood OneNO
PICK
000%1739265%
59Joel ThormanSB Nation000%1739265%
60Tom PelisseroUSA TodayNO
PICK
000%1739265%
61Chris WesselingNFL000%1729364%
62Dave RichardCBS000%1729364%
63Jarrett BellUSA TodayNO
PICK
000%1729364%
64Nathan JahnkeProFootballFocusNO
PICK
000%1729364%
65Sam MonsonProFootballFocusNO
PICK
000%1729364%
66Brent SobleskiBleacher Report000%1719464%
67John BreechCBS000%1719464%
68Mark SchlerethESPN000%1719464%
69Rod WoodsonWestwood OneNO
PICK
000%1719464%
70Boomer EsiasonCBSNO
PICK
000%1709564%
71James KohNFLNO
PICK
000%1709564%
72Marshall FaulkNFLNO
PICK
000%1709564%
73Mike FreemanBleacher Report000%1709564%
74Peter SchragerFOXNO
PICK
000%1709564%
75Frank SchwabYahooNO
PICK
000%1699663%
76Henry HodgsonNFL000%1699663%
77Keyshawn JohnsonESPN000%1699663%
78Kurt WarnerNFLNO
PICK
000%1699663%
79Lindsay H. JonesUSA TodayNO
PICK
000%1699663%
80PickwatchPickwatchNO
PICK
000%1699663%
81Rick DrummondProFootballFocusNO
PICK
000%1699663%
82Jason La CanforaCBS000%1689763%
83Khaled ElsayedProFootballFocusNO
PICK
000%1689763%
84Zach KruseBleacher Report000%1689763%
85Adam ScheinCBSNO
PICK
000%1679863%
86Bill LekasSiriusNO
PICK
000%1679863%
87Chris HansenBleacher Report000%1679863%
88Chris LissSiriusNO
PICK
000%1679863%
89Matt UffordSB Nation000%1679863%
90Mike TanierBleacher Report000%1679863%
91Bart ScottCBSNO
PICK
000%1669962%
92Eric AdelsonYahooNO
PICK
000%1669962%
93Merill HogeESPN000%1669962%
94Mike GarafoloFOXNO
PICK
000%16510062%
95Mike GolicESPN000%16510062%
96Neil HornsbyProFootballFocusNO
PICK
000%16510062%
97WalterFootballWalterFootballNO
PICK
000%16510062%
98David FucilloSB Nation000%16410161%
99Ryan FowlerFOXNO
PICK
000%16410161%
100Chris BrockmanNFLNO
PICK
000%16310261%
101Chris MortensenESPN000%16310261%
102Danny KellySB Nation000%16310261%
103John HalpinFOXNO
PICK
000%16310261%
104Ty SchalterBleacher Report000%16310261%
105Bill CowherCBSNO
PICK
000%16210361%
106Jim MillerSiriusNO
PICK
000%16210361%
107Stephen WhiteSB Nation000%16210361%
108Andrea HangstBleacher Report000%16110460%
109FOX.com EditorsFOXNO
PICK
000%16110460%
110Rich GannonSiriusNO
PICK
000%16110460%
111Adam MeyerFOXNO
PICK
000%16010560%
112Erik FrenzBleacher Report000%16010560%
113Ryan Van BibberSB Nation000%16010560%
114Joel BeallFOXNO
PICK
000%15910660%
115Mike DitkaESPN000%15910660%
116Warren SappNFLNO
PICK
000%15910660%
117Brandon TierneyCBSNO
PICK
000%15810759%
118PFT CommenterSB Nation000%15710859%
119TD DanielNFLNO
PICK
000%15710859%
120Tony GonzalezCBSNO
PICK
000%15710859%
121Ryan WilsonCBS000%15610958%
122Will BrinsonCBS000%15610958%
123Rivers McCownBleacher Report000%15411158%
124Melissa StarkNFLNO
PICK
000%15211357%
125Shaun O'HaraNFLNO
PICK
000%15211357%
126Chris TrapassoNFLNO
PICK
000%14911656%
127Sterling SharpeNFLNO
PICK
000%14212353%
128Adam RankNFLNO
PICK
000%14112453%
129Michael RobinsonNFLNO
PICK
000%13912652%
130Marcas GrantNFLNO
PICK
000%12514047%
131Braden GallSiriusNO
PICK
000%12114445%
132Jeff EricksonSiriusNO
PICK
000%12114445%
133Chris LawNFLNO
PICK
000%11814744%

244 thoughts on “2014 NFL Expert Picks

  1. Hate to point out another discrepancy, but you have Ditka picking the Ravens. ESPN.com’s NFL Expert Picks has him Picking the Ravens. I notice a little bit of a Ravens bias here.

    1. No that’s fine, thanks for pointing it out – Man, I hate ESPN (or at least whoever enters their picks).

      I was going to tweet earlier while looking at their page that only 3 ESPN experts picked the Ravens. Last week Cris Carter’s pick for the Indy and Cinci game flipped 3 times (check out the comments here):

      http://nflpickwatch.com/expert-pick-change/

      Guaranteed no bias, we just sometimes can’t keep up with their crazy changes. I wouldn’t mind, except Ditka’s picks were the last in out of everyone at ESPN!

      Anyway thanks – if you spot anything, let us know. We audit on Saturday and Sunday

  2. Jamey Eisenberg’s picks on here appear to be his “Against the Spread” picks. His “Straight Up” picks according to CBSSports.com were:

    New England, Seattle, Green Bay, and Denver.

    1. Hello – thanks for this. Can guarantee this was a change at CBS’s end, it definitely had the Ravens logo (rather than the abbreviation) and I found this notable at the time as he was the only CBS expert to pick the Ravens. Until he didn’t.

      Cheers for the heads up.

  3. Accuscore actually has Patriots to win, not Ravens. Game preview shows a 58% chance for NE to win, and Balt. just 41%. The playoff bracket that they put out has 53% Ravens, but this is inconsistent with the preview, and seems unlikely to be accurate given the game is at NE.

  4. Sorry again, but Bleacher report had typo, and Bengals/Browns pick was mis-labeled and were reversed. Think Bleacher report has corrected it now:

    Bengals: Bowen, Davenport, Freeman, Frenz, Gagnon, Hansen, Kruse, Miller, Schottey, Sobleski, Tomlinson

    Browns: Hangst, McCown, Schalter, Simms, Tanier

    1. Indeed – this has been fixed, thanks for the heads up. We tend not to check B/R too much because it’s all done ‘by hand’ so we wouldn’t expect any pick changes – in fact when they do, the B/R staff tend to change them with us anyway!

      Cheers

    1. I think one pattern is emerging over the last few years – Jackson, Carter and a couple of others at ESPN tend to put their full slate of picks in to meet the Thursday deadline and then change lots of picks at the weekend. We appreciate people giving us a shout to get them changed.

      We will still continue with a Sunday audit to pick up anything we haven’t already been made aware of.

      Cheers, Shaun

  5. Sunday Pick update:

    ESPN

    TeamRankings: Changed WAS to STL, changed ARI to KC
    Numberfire: Changed TEN to NYG
    Mike Golic: Changed TEN to NYG, changed CLE to IND
    Eric Allen: Changed from BAL to MIA
    Mike Ditka: Changed from BUF to DEN

    CBS

    Will Brinson Changed from CIN to PIT
    Dave Richard from TEN to NYG

    Accuscore

    Changed from no pick to PIT, changed from no pick to SEA

    Added Picks:

    Warren Sapp

  6. When reviewing a “previous” week, it would be nicer if “season” totals were only those totals through the week you’re reviewing (rather than “future” weeks as well).

Leave a Reply