Week 17 Against the Spread Expert Picks: Philadelphia Eagles @ New York Giants


Pickwatch is about more than just listing picks – in our weekly matchup breakdowns we rank experts by their against the spread accuracy, highlight those who pick just these two teams best, and show you how hard it has been on average to predict them at home and on the road.

KEY:
Overall: The expert’s overall correct pick %  picking this team’s games vs the closing spread
Home: The expert’s correct pick % picking only this team’s home games vs the closing spread
Road: The expert’s correct pick % picking only this team’s road games vs the closing spread
GREENThe expert(s) with the best combined correct pick percentage when picking the road team on the road, and the home team at home

Expert ATS Standings for 2014 with all weekly data and last 5 weeks score

Click here to go back to the main ATS Picks page

Matchup Guides:

CAR @ ATL    CLE @ BAL    DAL @ WAS    IND @ TEN    JAX @ HOU    CHI @ MIN   NYJ @ MIA    SD @ KC
BUF @ NE     NO @ TB    PHI @ NYG    OAK @ DEN    DET @ GB    ARI @ SF    STL @ SEA    CIN @ PIT

 

Philadelphia Eagles @ New York Giants
Rank Expert Affiliation Overall Home Road Pick Rank Expert Affiliation Overall Home Road Pick
1 Chase Keefer Las Vegas Sun 80% 75% 86% PHI 1 Jason La Canfora CBS 87% 86% 88% PHI
2 Tim Cowlishaw DallasNews.com 74% 63% 86% NYG 2 Consensus Pick Pickwatch 80% 86% 75% NYG
3 Will Brinson CBS 62% 38% 86% PHI 3 FiveThirtyEight FiveThirtyEight 79% 86% 71% PHI
4 Pickwatch Pickwatch 65% 50% 80% NYG 4 Dave Richard CBS 68% 86% 50% NYG
5 David Moore DallasNews.com 73% 75% 71% NYG 5 David Moore DallasNews.com 64% 86% 43% NYG
6 Bob Glauber Newsday 71% 71% 71% 6 Neil Greenberg Washington Post 55% 86% 25% PHI
7 Dana Larson DallasNews.com 67% 63% 71% NYG 7 Kimberley A Martin Newsday 77% 83% 71%
8 Kevin Sherrington DallasNews.com 61% 50% 71% PHI 8 Bob Glauber Newsday 56% 83% 29%
9 Rick Gosselin DallasNews.com 54% 38% 71% NYG 9 Rainer Sabin DallasNews.com 71% 71% 71% NYG
10 Ryan Wilson CBS 48% 25% 71% NYG 10 Michael Whitmer Boston Globe 67% 71% 63% PHI
11 Neil Greenberg Washington Post 72% 88% 57% PHI 11 Dana Larson DallasNews.com 64% 71% 57% NYG
12 Jason La Canfora CBS 66% 75% 57% PHI 12 Jim McBride Boston Globe 61% 71% 50% PHI
13 FiveThirtyEight FiveThirtyEight 66% 75% 57% PHI 13 Shalise Young Boston Globe 61% 71% 50% NYG
14 Newy Scruggs DallasNews.com 54% 50% 57% PHI 14 Kevin Sherrington DallasNews.com 57% 71% 43% PHI
15 Numberfire Numberfire 54% 50% 57% PHI 15 John Breech CBS 54% 71% 38% NYG
16 Vic Tafur SFGate 54% 50% 57% NYG 16 Ryan Wilson CBS 54% 71% 38% NYG
17 Frank Schwab Yahoo 54% 50% 57% NYG 17 Tom Rock Newsday 48% 67% 29%
18 Dave Richard CBS 47% 38% 57% NYG 18 Pete Prisco CBS 60% 57% 63% NYG
19 Jamey Eisenberg CBS 47% 38% 57% NYG 19 Will Brinson CBS 60% 57% 63% PHI
20 Consensus Pick Pickwatch 68% 86% 50% NYG 20 Craig Miller DallasNews.com 57% 57% 57% NYG
21 Craig Miller DallasNews.com 71% 100% 43% NYG 21 Josh Katzowitz CBS 54% 57% 50% PHI
22 John Boell Newsday 59% 75% 43% PHI 22 John Boell Newsday 54% 57% 50% PHI
23 Ben Volin Boston Globe 53% 63% 43% PHI 23 Newy Scruggs DallasNews.com 50% 57% 43% PHI
24 Christopher Gasper Boston Globe 53% 63% 43% NYG 24 Jamey Eisenberg CBS 41% 57% 25% NYG
25 Jim McBride Boston Globe 53% 63% 43% PHI 25 Frank Schwab Yahoo 41% 57% 25% NYG
26 Josh Katzowitz CBS 53% 63% 43% PHI 26 Sean Leahy Boston Globe 55% 50% 60%
27 Rainer Sabin DallasNews.com 53% 63% 43% NYG 27 Ben Volin Boston Globe 59% 43% 75% PHI
28 Bill Simmons Grantland 53% 63% 43% NYG 28 Sam Farmer LA Times 53% 43% 63% PHI
29 Walterfootball Walterfootball 53% 63% 43% NYG 29 Teamrankings Teamrankings 53% 43% 63% PHI
30 Mario Mergola XNSports/AOL 53% 63% 43% NYG 30 Brandon George DallasNews.com 50% 43% 57% NYG
31 Pete Prisco CBS 46% 50% 43% NYG 31 Rick Gosselin DallasNews.com 50% 43% 57% NYG
32 Shalise Young Boston Globe 40% 38% 43% NYG 32 Chase Keefer Las Vegas Sun 46% 43% 50% PHI
33 Sam Farmer LA Times 40% 38% 43% PHI 33 Tim Cowlishaw DallasNews.com 43% 43% 43% NYG
34 Teamrankings Teamrankings 40% 38% 43% PHI 34 Christopher Gasper Boston Globe 40% 43% 38% NYG
35 Brandon George DallasNews.com 28% 13% 43% NYG 35 Pickwatch Pickwatch 37% 40% 33% NYG
36 Sean Leahy Boston Globe 53% 67% 40% 36 Dave Tuley ESPN 42% 33% 50% PHI
37 Kimberley A Martin Newsday 50% 71% 29% 37 Vic Tafur SFGate 46% 29% 63% NYG
38 John Breech CBS 46% 63% 29% NYG 38 Walterfootball Walterfootball 39% 29% 50% NYG
39 Tom Rock Newsday 21% 14% 29% 39 Mario Mergola XNSports/AOL 39% 29% 50% NYG
40 Dave Tuley ESPN 29% 33% 25% PHI 40 Bill Simmons Grantland 21% 29% 14% NYG
41 Michael Whitmer Boston Globe 26% 38% 14% PHI 41 Numberfire Numberfire 32% 14% 50% PHI
Average Home Road Average Home Road
54% 56% 52% 54% 58% 51%