‘Clutch’ games are those games between 50-74% expert consensus (found at the bottom of weekly pick pages). These are usually the hardest matchups to predict, as they reflect the level of disagreement amongst experts at anywhere from 50/50 to 74/26 splits. Anyone can take a 10-0 team to beat a 1-9 team, but who do you take when both teams are 5-5? That’s where clutch picking comes in. This rates the experts based on their success rate in those games that are hardest to predict.