AFC South


How every NFL expert has fared when picking the AFC South – updated through Week 17.

These tables are sorted by Overall record when picking the team, then by home and road records (depending on whether next week’s game is home or away) when picking each team. You may also want to compare this information with the expert’s overall record, before checking who they have picked this week.

Colts Jaguars
Rank Expert Affiliation Overall Home Road Rank Expert Affiliation Overall Home Road
1 Gregg Rosenthal NFL 73.21% 71% 75% 1 Mike Ditka ESPN 87% 88% 86%
2 Chris Brockman NFL 66.96% 71% 63% 2 Brian Baldinger NFL 83% 100% 67%
3 Pete O’Brien USA Today 66.96% 71% 63% 3 Ryan Wilson CBS 80% 75% 86%
4 Simon Samano USA Today 66.96% 71% 63% 4 Pickwatch Pickwatch 80% 75% 86%
5 Don Banks Sports Illustrated 66.96% 71% 63% 5 Chris Brockman NFL 79% 88% 71%
6 K.C. Joyner ESPN 66.96% 71% 63% 6 Dave Richard CBS 79% 100% 57%
7 Neil Hornsby ProFootballFocus 66.96% 71% 63% 7 Adam Meyer FOX 79% 100% 57%
8 Dan Hanzus NFL 66.96% 71% 63% 8 Adam Schefter ESPN 79% 100% 57%
9 Erik Frenz Bleacher Report 66.96% 71% 63% 9 Matt Smith NFL 73% 80% 67%
10 Merill Hoge ESPN 66.07% 57% 75% 10 Lindsay H. Jones USA Today 73% 75% 71%
11 Seth Wickersham ESPN 66.07% 57% 75% 11 Jarrett Bell USA Today 73% 75% 71%
12 Jarrett Bell USA Today 66.07% 57% 75% 12 Marshall Faulk NFL 73% 75% 71%
13 Andrea Hangst Bleacher Report 60.71% 71% 50% 13 Matt Miller Bleacher Report 73% 75% 71%
14 John Breech CBS 60.71% 71% 50% 14 Mike Freeman Bleacher Report 73% 75% 71%
15 Brad Gagnon Bleacher Report 60.71% 71% 50% 15 Ty Schalter Bleacher Report 72% 88% 57%
16 Chris Mortensen ESPN 60.71% 71% 50% 16 Pete O’Brien USA Today 72% 88% 57%
17 Melissa Stark NFL 60.71% 71% 50% 17 Tom Jackson ESPN 72% 88% 57%
18 Knox Bardeen Bleacher Report 60.71% 71% 50% 18 Michael Fabiano NFL 72% 88% 57%
19 Ron Jaworski ESPN 59.82% 57% 63% 19 K.C. Joyner ESPN 72% 88% 57%
20 Steve Mariucci NFL 59.82% 57% 63% 20 Chris Law NFL 72% 88% 57%
21 Sam Monson ProFootballFocus 59.82% 57% 63% 21 Rich Eisen NFL 72% 88% 57%
22 Nathan Jahnke ProFootballFocus 59.82% 57% 63% 22 Matt Bowen Bleacher Report 72% 88% 57%
23 Kevin Patra NFL 59.82% 57% 63% 23 Michael Silver NFL 72% 88% 57%
24 Matt Bowen Bleacher Report 59.82% 57% 63% 24 Cris Carter ESPN 72% 88% 57%
25 Rich Eisen NFL 59.82% 57% 63% 25 Warren Sapp NFL 72% 88% 57%
26 Ryan Wilson CBS 59.82% 57% 63% 26 Jim Corbett USA Today 72% 88% 57%
27 Frank Schwab Yahoo 59.82% 57% 63% 27 Zach Kruse Bleacher Report 72% 88% 57%
28 Henry Hodgson NFL 59.82% 57% 63% 28 Mark Schlereth ESPN 72% 88% 57%
29 Pete Prisco CBS 59.82% 57% 63% 29 Heath Evans NFL 72% 88% 57%
30 Heath Evans NFL 59.82% 57% 63% 30 Keyshawn Johnson ESPN 72% 88% 57%
31 Josh Katzowitz CBS 59.82% 57% 63% 31 Josh Katzowitz CBS 72% 88% 57%
32 Gordon McGuinness ProFootballFocus 59.82% 57% 63% 32 Jason La Canfora CBS 72% 88% 57%
33 Will Brinson CBS 58.93% 43% 75% 33 Vinnie Iyer Sporting News 72% 88% 57%
34 Matt Smith NFL 58.33% 33% 83% 34 Michael Irvin NFL 72% 88% 57%
35 Steve Wyche NFL 56.25% 50% 63% 35 Gregg Rosenthal NFL 72% 88% 57%
36 Dave Damashek NFL 54.76% 67% 43% 36 Prediction Machine CBS 72% 88% 57%
37 Joel Beall FOX 53.57% 57% 50% 37 Nate Davis USA Today 72% 88% 57%
38 Cris Carter ESPN 53.57% 57% 50% 38 Michael David Smith PFT 72% 88% 57%
39 Prediction Machine CBS 53.57% 57% 50% 39 Whatifsports FOX 72% 88% 57%
40 Accuscore Accuscore 53.57% 57% 50% 40 Ryan Fowler FOX 72% 88% 57%
41 Black Tie NFL 53.57% 57% 50% 41 Shaun O’Hara NFL 72% 88% 57%
42 Tom Jackson ESPN 53.57% 57% 50% 42 Adam Rank NFL 71% 86% 57%
43 Michael Fabiano NFL 53.57% 57% 50% 43 Seth Wickersham ESPN 67% 63% 71%
44 Jamey Eisenberg CBS 53.57% 57% 50% 44 Dan Hanzus NFL 67% 63% 71%
45 Chris Law NFL 53.57% 57% 50% 45 Steve Mariucci NFL 66% 75% 57%
46 Michael Silver NFL 53.57% 57% 50% 46 Nathan Jahnke ProFootballFocus 66% 75% 57%
47 Chris Hansen Bleacher Report 53.57% 57% 50% 47 Jamey Eisenberg CBS 66% 75% 57%
48 Mike Golic ESPN 53.57% 57% 50% 48 Brad Gagnon Bleacher Report 66% 75% 57%
49 Elliot Harrison NFL 53.57% 57% 50% 49 Frank Schwab Yahoo 66% 75% 57%
50 Mike Florio PFT 53.57% 57% 50% 50 Pete Prisco CBS 66% 75% 57%
51 Shaun O’Hara NFL 53.57% 57% 50% 51 Erik Frenz Bleacher Report 66% 75% 57%
52 Mike Freeman Bleacher Report 53.57% 57% 50% 52 Tom Pelissero USA Today 66% 75% 57%
53 John Halpin FOX 52.68% 43% 63% 53 Mike Florio PFT 66% 75% 57%
54 Nate Davis USA Today 52.68% 43% 63% 54 Melissa Stark NFL 66% 75% 57%
55 Rick Drummond ProFootballFocus 52.68% 43% 63% 55 Sterling Sharpe NFL 66% 75% 57%
56 Michael David Smith PFT 52.68% 43% 63% 56 Knox Bardeen Bleacher Report 66% 75% 57%
57 Tyson Langland Bleacher Report 52.68% 43% 63% 57 Accuscore Accuscore 66% 75% 57%
58 Steve Palazzolo ProFootballFocus 52.68% 43% 63% 58 Rick Drummond ProFootballFocus 66% 75% 57%
59 Eric Allen ESPN 52.68% 43% 63% 59 John Breech CBS 66% 75% 57%
60 Lindsay H. Jones USA Today 52.68% 43% 63% 60 Ben Stockwell ProFootballFocus 66% 75% 57%
61 Marc Sessler NFL 51.79% 29% 75% 61 NFL FAN PICKS NFL 66% 75% 57%
62 Marshall Faulk NFL 50.00% 43% 57% 62 Chris Hansen Bleacher Report 66% 75% 57%
63 Brian Baldinger NFL 47.92% 33% 63% 63 Mike Golic ESPN 66% 75% 57%
64 Michael Irvin NFL 47.32% 57% 38% 64 Neil Hornsby ProFootballFocus 66% 75% 57%
65 Ty Schalter Bleacher Report 46.43% 43% 50% 65 Pick ‘em ESPN 66% 75% 57%
66 Warren Sapp NFL 46.43% 43% 50% 66 Yahoo Users Yahoo 66% 75% 57%
67 Sterling Sharpe NFL 46.43% 43% 50% 67 Eric Allen ESPN 66% 75% 57%
68 Chris Wesseling NFL 46.43% 43% 50% 68 Kurt Warner NFL 66% 75% 57%
69 Whatifsports FOX 46.43% 43% 50% 69 Michael Schottey Bleacher Report 66% 75% 57%
70 Ben Stockwell ProFootballFocus 46.43% 43% 50% 70 Andrea Hangst Bleacher Report 66% 75% 57%
71 Matt Miller Bleacher Report 46.43% 43% 50% 71 Tyson Langland Bleacher Report 66% 75% 57%
72 Pickwatch Pickwatch 46.43% 43% 50% 72 Merill Hoge ESPN 66% 75% 57%
73 Jim Corbett USA Today 46.43% 43% 50% 73 Les Carpenter Yahoo 66% 60% 71%
74 NFL FAN PICKS NFL 46.43% 43% 50% 74 Khaled Elsayed ProFootballFocus 65% 88% 43%
75 Pick ‘em ESPN 46.43% 43% 50% 75 Steve Wyche NFL 63% 75% 50%
76 Yahoo Users Yahoo 46.43% 43% 50% 76 Ron Jaworski ESPN 60% 63% 57%
77 Michael Schottey Bleacher Report 46.43% 43% 50% 77 Elliot Harrison NFL 60% 63% 57%
78 Vinnie Iyer Sporting News 46.43% 43% 50% 78 Marc Sessler NFL 60% 63% 57%
79 Adam Meyer FOX 46.43% 43% 50% 79 Don Banks Sports Illustrated 60% 63% 57%
80 Jason La Canfora CBS 45.54% 29% 63% 80 Will Brinson CBS 60% 63% 57%
81 Keyshawn Johnson ESPN 45.54% 29% 63% 81 Steve Palazzolo ProFootballFocus 60% 63% 57%
82 Les Carpenter Yahoo 41.67% 33% 50% 82 Henry Hodgson NFL 60% 63% 57%
83 Mike Ditka ESPN 41.07% 57% 25% 83 Kevin Patra NFL 60% 63% 57%
84 Tom Pelissero USA Today 40.18% 43% 38% 84 Chris Wesseling NFL 60% 63% 57%
85 Dave Richard CBS 40.18% 43% 38% 85 Black Tie NFL 59% 75% 43%
86 Zach Kruse Bleacher Report 39.29% 29% 50% 86 John Halpin FOX 59% 75% 43%
87 Adam Rank NFL 39.29% 29% 50% 87 Joel Beall FOX 59% 75% 43%
88 Ryan Fowler FOX 33.04% 29% 38% 88 Chris Mortensen ESPN 59% 75% 43%
89 Adam Schefter ESPN 33.04% 29% 38% 89 Dave Damashek NFL 59% 75% 43%
90 Kurt Warner NFL 33.04% 29% 38% 90 Simon Samano USA Today 54% 50% 57%
91 Mark Schlereth ESPN 32.14% 14% 50% 91 Sam Monson ProFootballFocus 54% 50% 57%
92 Khaled Elsayed ProFootballFocus 27.68% 43% 13% 92 Gordon McGuinness ProFootballFocus 53% 63% 43%
93 Coin Toss None 26.79% 29% 25% 93 Coin Toss None 34% 25% 43%
Texans Titans
Rank Expert Affiliation Overall Home Road Rank Expert Affiliation Overall Home Road
1 Michael Silver NFL 88% 75% 100% 1 Nate Davis USA Today 79% 71% 88%
2 Chris Brockman NFL 81% 63% 100% 2 Pete O’Brien USA Today 79% 71% 88%
3 Andrea Hangst Bleacher Report 81% 63% 100% 3 Michael Fabiano NFL 79% 71% 88%
4 Don Banks Sports Illustrated 81% 63% 100% 4 Michael David Smith PFT 79% 71% 88%
5 Jamey Eisenberg CBS 81% 63% 100% 5 Chris Wesseling NFL 79% 71% 88%
6 Seth Wickersham ESPN 81% 63% 100% 6 Matt Bowen Bleacher Report 79% 71% 88%
7 Josh Katzowitz CBS 81% 63% 100% 7 Mike Freeman Bleacher Report 79% 71% 88%
8 Mike Freeman Bleacher Report 81% 63% 100% 8 Dave Damashek NFL 77% 67% 88%
9 Mike Ditka ESPN 80% 75% 86% 9 Steve Wyche NFL 77% 67% 88%
10 Melissa Stark NFL 80% 75% 86% 10 John Halpin FOX 73% 71% 75%
11 Matt Smith NFL 80% 60% 100% 11 Nathan Jahnke ProFootballFocus 73% 71% 75%
12 Brian Baldinger NFL 79% 57% 100% 12 Jamey Eisenberg CBS 73% 71% 75%
13 Pete Prisco CBS 75% 50% 100% 13 Adam Rank NFL 73% 71% 75%
14 Will Brinson CBS 75% 50% 100% 14 K.C. Joyner ESPN 73% 71% 75%
15 Ron Jaworski ESPN 74% 63% 86% 15 Ben Stockwell ProFootballFocus 73% 71% 75%
16 Chris Hansen Bleacher Report 74% 63% 86% 16 Whatifsports FOX 73% 71% 75%
17 Michael Schottey Bleacher Report 74% 63% 86% 17 Tyson Langland Bleacher Report 73% 71% 75%
18 Steve Mariucci NFL 74% 63% 86% 18 Michael Schottey Bleacher Report 73% 71% 75%
19 K.C. Joyner ESPN 74% 63% 86% 19 Accuscore Accuscore 72% 57% 88%
20 Matt Bowen Bleacher Report 74% 63% 86% 20 Joel Beall FOX 72% 57% 88%
21 Adam Meyer FOX 74% 63% 86% 21 Kevin Patra NFL 72% 57% 88%
22 Tyson Langland Bleacher Report 74% 63% 86% 22 John Breech CBS 72% 57% 88%
23 Cris Carter ESPN 74% 63% 86% 23 Warren Sapp NFL 72% 57% 88%
24 Frank Schwab Yahoo 74% 63% 86% 24 Pickwatch Pickwatch 72% 57% 88%
25 Henry Hodgson NFL 74% 63% 86% 25 Merill Hoge ESPN 72% 57% 88%
26 Keyshawn Johnson ESPN 74% 63% 86% 26 Eric Allen ESPN 72% 57% 88%
27 Erik Frenz Bleacher Report 74% 63% 86% 27 Ron Jaworski ESPN 67% 71% 63%
28 Vinnie Iyer Sporting News 74% 63% 86% 28 Simon Samano USA Today 67% 71% 63%
29 Lindsay H. Jones USA Today 74% 63% 86% 29 Brad Gagnon Bleacher Report 67% 71% 63%
30 Ryan Wilson CBS 73% 75% 71% 30 Sam Monson ProFootballFocus 67% 71% 63%
31 Pickwatch Pickwatch 73% 75% 71% 31 Knox Bardeen Bleacher Report 67% 71% 63%
32 Tom Jackson ESPN 73% 75% 71% 32 Andrea Hangst Bleacher Report 67% 71% 63%
33 Brad Gagnon Bleacher Report 69% 38% 100% 33 Tom Jackson ESPN 67% 71% 63%
34 Chris Mortensen ESPN 69% 38% 100% 34 Jarrett Bell USA Today 67% 71% 63%
35 Jarrett Bell USA Today 68% 50% 86% 35 Neil Hornsby ProFootballFocus 67% 71% 63%
36 John Halpin FOX 68% 50% 86% 36 Matt Smith NFL 67% 50% 83%
37 Khaled Elsayed ProFootballFocus 68% 50% 86% 37 Les Carpenter Yahoo 67% 67% 67%
38 Dave Richard CBS 68% 50% 86% 38 Elliot Harrison NFL 66% 57% 75%
39 Sam Monson ProFootballFocus 68% 50% 86% 39 Chris Brockman NFL 66% 57% 75%
40 Rich Eisen NFL 68% 50% 86% 40 Rick Drummond ProFootballFocus 66% 57% 75%
41 Steve Palazzolo ProFootballFocus 68% 50% 86% 41 Rich Eisen NFL 66% 57% 75%
42 Mike Florio PFT 68% 50% 86% 42 NFL FAN PICKS NFL 66% 57% 75%
43 Sterling Sharpe NFL 68% 50% 86% 43 Mike Ditka ESPN 66% 57% 75%
44 Michael Irvin NFL 68% 50% 86% 44 Chris Hansen Bleacher Report 66% 57% 75%
45 Jason La Canfora CBS 67% 63% 71% 45 Matt Miller Bleacher Report 66% 57% 75%
46 Nate Davis USA Today 67% 63% 71% 46 Pick ‘em ESPN 66% 57% 75%
47 Accuscore Accuscore 67% 63% 71% 47 Yahoo Users Yahoo 66% 57% 75%
48 Rick Drummond ProFootballFocus 67% 63% 71% 48 Michael Irvin NFL 66% 57% 75%
49 Whatifsports FOX 67% 63% 71% 49 Gregg Rosenthal NFL 65% 43% 88%
50 NFL FAN PICKS NFL 67% 63% 71% 50 Jim Corbett USA Today 65% 43% 88%
51 Mike Golic ESPN 67% 63% 71% 51 Marshall Faulk NFL 63% 43% 83%
52 Elliot Harrison NFL 67% 63% 71% 52 Henry Hodgson NFL 61% 71% 50%
53 Pick ‘em ESPN 67% 63% 71% 53 Tom Pelissero USA Today 61% 71% 50%
54 Yahoo Users Yahoo 67% 63% 71% 54 Steve Mariucci NFL 60% 57% 63%
55 Pete O’Brien USA Today 67% 63% 71% 55 Black Tie NFL 60% 57% 63%
56 Nathan Jahnke ProFootballFocus 67% 63% 71% 56 Ty Schalter Bleacher Report 60% 57% 63%
57 Warren Sapp NFL 67% 63% 71% 57 Seth Wickersham ESPN 60% 57% 63%
58 Merill Hoge ESPN 67% 63% 71% 58 Pete Prisco CBS 60% 57% 63%
59 Jim Corbett USA Today 67% 63% 71% 59 Mike Florio PFT 60% 57% 63%
60 Heath Evans NFL 67% 63% 71% 60 Ryan Wilson CBS 60% 57% 63%
61 Dan Hanzus NFL 67% 63% 71% 61 Adam Meyer FOX 60% 57% 63%
62 Mark Schlereth ESPN 61% 50% 71% 62 Cris Carter ESPN 60% 57% 63%
63 Prediction Machine CBS 61% 50% 71% 63 Chris Mortensen ESPN 60% 57% 63%
64 Simon Samano USA Today 61% 50% 71% 64 Mark Schlereth ESPN 60% 57% 63%
65 Black Tie NFL 61% 50% 71% 65 Zach Kruse Bleacher Report 60% 57% 63%
66 Dave Damashek NFL 61% 50% 71% 66 Mike Golic ESPN 60% 57% 63%
67 Matt Miller Bleacher Report 61% 50% 71% 67 Frank Schwab Yahoo 59% 43% 75%
68 Eric Allen ESPN 61% 50% 71% 68 Prediction Machine CBS 59% 43% 75%
69 Chris Law NFL 61% 50% 71% 69 Khaled Elsayed ProFootballFocus 59% 43% 75%
70 Adam Rank NFL 60% 63% 57% 70 Dave Richard CBS 59% 43% 75%
71 Zach Kruse Bleacher Report 60% 63% 57% 71 Adam Schefter ESPN 59% 43% 75%
72 Gregg Rosenthal NFL 60% 63% 57% 72 Ryan Fowler FOX 59% 43% 75%
73 Michael David Smith PFT 60% 63% 57% 73 Josh Katzowitz CBS 59% 43% 75%
74 Kevin Patra NFL 60% 63% 57% 74 Vinnie Iyer Sporting News 59% 43% 75%
75 John Breech CBS 60% 63% 57% 75 Shaun O’Hara NFL 59% 43% 75%
76 Marshall Faulk NFL 60% 63% 57% 76 Will Brinson CBS 54% 71% 38%
77 Kurt Warner NFL 60% 63% 57% 77 Brian Baldinger NFL 54% 33% 75%
78 Shaun O’Hara NFL 60% 63% 57% 78 Don Banks Sports Illustrated 54% 57% 50%
79 Knox Bardeen Bleacher Report 60% 63% 57% 79 Erik Frenz Bleacher Report 54% 57% 50%
80 Michael Fabiano NFL 60% 63% 57% 80 Lindsay H. Jones USA Today 54% 57% 50%
81 Tom Pelissero USA Today 60% 63% 57% 81 Steve Palazzolo ProFootballFocus 53% 43% 63%
82 Les Carpenter Yahoo 59% 57% 60% 82 Gordon McGuinness ProFootballFocus 53% 43% 63%
83 Steve Wyche NFL 58% 50% 67% 83 Chris Law NFL 53% 43% 63%
84 Joel Beall FOX 54% 38% 71% 84 Michael Silver NFL 53% 43% 63%
85 Adam Schefter ESPN 54% 38% 71% 85 Heath Evans NFL 53% 43% 63%
86 Marc Sessler NFL 54% 50% 57% 86 Kurt Warner NFL 53% 43% 63%
87 Ryan Fowler FOX 54% 50% 57% 87 Marc Sessler NFL 52% 29% 75%
88 Neil Hornsby ProFootballFocus 54% 50% 57% 88 Dan Hanzus NFL 46% 43% 50%
89 Ben Stockwell ProFootballFocus 53% 63% 43% 89 Keyshawn Johnson ESPN 46% 43% 50%
90 Gordon McGuinness ProFootballFocus 53% 63% 43% 90 Melissa Stark NFL 46% 29% 63%
91 Chris Wesseling NFL 47% 38% 57% 91 Jason La Canfora CBS 46% 29% 63%
92 Ty Schalter Bleacher Report 46% 50% 43% 92 Sterling Sharpe NFL 45% 14% 75%
93 Coin Toss None 33% 38% 29% 93 Coin Toss None 32% 14% 50%